Saturday 28 May 2022

Return of the Phantom - Knowing the Future (Request for Assistance)

Written by Morpheus Kitami

Yes, up and down all those flights of stairs

Before I returned to Madame Giry, I thought it best to check out the dressing rooms, since I haven't been there yet in this time period. Unfortunately nobody's there yet. I'm almost glad there haven't been many real puzzles yet, because having to navigate across this game is tedious.

I don't feel like this is the kind of game that should be giving sly 
nods towards the conventions of the genre

After returning to Giry, she tells me to refer to the colored frames as "good luck charms", before opening box no. 5 with a flourish. Inside, there's a note from the Opera Ghost, telling me to leave Miss Daae alone or I will suffer a great malady. What's next isn't a mystery, I already found the secret door; In the left column, which I thought was a clue. No, I just got lucky, there's a right column too. All I need is a key.

Now, since I need to find a key anyway, I'll walk back through the house. If I were treating this seriously, I'd take that fire ax and use that to break down the door, but the game developers aren't likely to be following my train of thought. I guess the manager would be a bit miffed, but I'm trying to prevent a murder and the loss of untold francs! What's one column compared to that?

Something tells me this isn't going to be as useful as it seems

On my way back, I realize that a small graphic on one of the boxes backstage is actually a hook...which I can use to make a grappling hook. Looking at the stage, apparently there's a shortcut into the orchestra pit.

I'm genuinely surprised that the game will kill me, allows me to kill 
myself in this fashion, and be merciful about it

...and I'm dead. The game then deposits me back on-stage, seemingly no worse for the wear. Onto the dressing rooms...again. Christine is back from here errands and we can hear her singing voice. Talking to Christine reveals a lot about past Raoul and Christine's relationships. They knew each other as children, but lost touch until recently, and Raoul's been very supportive of her career. Her father, who is dead, sent the "angel of music" to her. She never sees him, just hears his voice from the walls. He doesn't appear when anyone else is in the room. You know, it bothers me that people supposedly speaking French, but translated into English for the sake of the audience, then inside that translation speak French.

Raoul can't be bothered to hack up someone who murdered someone,
but someone getting mushy with a woman who thinks she's his girlfriend, oh, no!

But surprisingly, she's been having dreams just like present Christine about a masked man. At this point she sends me off so she can practice with the angel of music. Naturally, Raoul decides to listen in at the door. The angel comes in, and speaks romantically to Christine, who responds likewise. Raoul, despite not being the Raoul in a relationship with her, decides he should break in. Now I can use the axe. That's the emergency. Ha! The game implies the mirror is a door, but we can't do anything.

I'm guessing if we hacked up the phantom this would get a significantly higher age rating

Some time later, when Raoul finally makes it back to the office, the manager and Raoul are discussing what has happened to her. Then Christine walks in, and apparently nothing awful has happened, she even got Raoul a complementary box seat ticket. Uh-oh. I smell a trap! Not quite, but the ticket is with a note that says to meet her after the performance, because she's in danger.

Well, we know she's not going to die, since the other Christine will exist

Once again, the opera starts...and then the Phantom makes his move. In this case, he rappels down a rope, and with a swing of his cape disappears, along with Christine. Why he didn't just keep her in his dungeon...? I dunno. One hour later...

Oh, his name is Richard! That's helpful

Much like in the present, my friend wants me to investigate. I should talk with Jacques, he says, the man under the stairs.

The horror, the horror

I feel like the shock of this is lessened somewhat by the fact that I had to walk all this way and I barely knew the man. We already know the Phantom murdered someone. The Phantom dropped the key here, much to my surprise. I thought I would have to do something for once, instead of just summarizing the events of the game. I know a few of you said you never beat this game, and at this point I'm wondering why. Even a child could get this far. (This, as it turns out, was the wrong thing to say)

Doesn't seem like anything, but as I'm examining the upstairs area, it occurs to me that I never found out what the "easy" interface is. Oh, just the standard Lucasarts-style interface, where you don't have to hold down your mouse button to see what's in an area. This is all wrong! You instead have "standard" and "ass backwards".

You know, I don't really care if one of the architects stuck one on top of a door!

From the Phantom's box, I can enter a secret shaft. Three floors, but I can't unlock the top door just yet. Down it is. To the sewers and catacombs...and its a maze. Its a maze. Just what I wanted with this walking speed. There are gates, there are drains, there is just no consistency to this map. The game has the audacity to act offended when I try the key on those gates too, so the game is really just screwing with me at this point.

By the way, I know I said I was going to try the easy mode, but there's no way in hell I'm doing this maze again. There's no way in hell I would do this if I wasn't blogging about it. At least text adventure mazes are shorter. 


Oh, you thought I was done!

The maze is a particularly cruel one, at least for a graphical adventure. There is no way in hell you're getting out of here without making a map. There are too many rooms that just lead back to an earlier room, and at the end a series of rooms that aren't even distinguishable from each other as a final, **** you. The only way to figure out where you are is to walk to a new room, and then back to the room just outside this section of maze. If you can't, well, mark off that exit and reload. Hope you didn't save in the wrong place or anything, and you remember where you are. I'm harping on it, but uh, you'll understand considering this has been a shorter entry and I still needed to ask for assistance.

Is this supposed to be an insult towards Indiana Jones? That didn't work well, did it?

The maze ends in front of a locked door, next to an adventurer, possibly from the early 1800s. He has a sword I can take.


Yes, I definitely know what I'm doing

And I'm dead, but the game just returns me to the start of the room

Since this is the only room left, outside of the endless same room maze back there, I have no choice but to try to solve this puzzle now. Let's see, there's no nearby hint. Twenty six switches, I can only pull four, and those four can be in any order, so I guess 416 possible combinations. If it takes me 30 seconds to do one solution that's about 3 and a half hours dedicated to this puzzle alone. Brute force is NOT an option. There are three different designs of skull, none of which are limited to 4. None of the items I have work. Does the door open if I chose a number of skulls with the same pattern from top to bottom? There are two, and I try both, neither work. Clearly, this is a find the password puzzle, not one of any skill on my part.

The map, yes, it is the ugliest maze ever made

(Any marks on the map that end in a one-way connection to nowhere just mean I couldn't follow my path back to the entrance of that section of the maze)

So I reload earlier in the game, before the maze, and look around. There's nothing back in the Opera House. Request for assistance time. Is there anything I missed in the maze? Were I not blogging about this game, I would have searched a walkthrough the second I realized this maze was that bad, assuming I didn't give up before then. If not, what am I missing?

This Session: 2 hours 10 minutes
Total time: 3 h 50 m

Score: 163

Inventory: Red frame, lantern, letter, notice, rope with hook, blue frame, yellow frame, crumpled note, piece of paper, key, sword


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. Okay, here it comes, Morpheus. These are all hints, the first being a vague pointer in the right direction, the last one containing the outright solution. Good luck!

    1. Gur ahzore bs fjvgpurf znl erzvaq lbh bs fbzrguvat.
    2. Gurer ner gjragl-fvk yrggref va gur nycunorg.
    3. Jub perngrq gur znmr?
    4. Gur cnffjbeq vf n anzr.
    5. Gur cnffjbeq vf gur cunagbz'f erny anzr.
    6. Gur cunagbz'f erny anzr vf Revx.
    7. Chfu fjvgpurf svir, rvtugrra, avar, naq ryrira.

    1. Ah, I see, the game told me about this, but I didn't figure this would be it. Guess the game actually got one over on me.

  3. ah, any maze that can't be solved by just following the wall in one direction is a maze too much for me these days!

    I'm assuming you're supposed to have found something that tells you about the switch puzzle?

    Guess I'll read Will's hints above and see for myself!

    1. Yeah, this is just the most infuriating kind of maze, and because of that, I didn't realize I already had the information for this switch puzzle.

  4. I hear you, Morpheus. That bloody maze is the reason why I guessed such a low rating for this game.

    1. Yeah, I can see where that maze is a sticking point for anyone playing this game. Its an utterly miserable experience that actually having to solve drags the entire game down from mundane to tedious.
      And that reminds me, spoilers for Dark Seed 2...
      Jul va Tbq'f anzr Orafba ybirq znmrf fb zhpu V'yy arire xabj. Gur raq tnzr gb gung gvgyr vf whfg bar ybat cerpvfr znmr. Gung vg jnfa'g gur svefg gvzr ur qvq vg vf vashevngvat. Vs ur erhfrf gur fnzr cybg gjvfgf gbb V'z tbvat gb or irel hcfrg.

    2. When I played it was in easy mode, which I seem to remember having a smaller, easier maze. I might've guessed even lower too had I known just how bad the harder maze is.

    3. I wouldn't have expected you to have gone for the easier mode, but in this case that worked out rather well. I suspect the game is tolerable on easy...sort of how like the "standard" navigation mode is unnecessarily complex. At the very least I hope it removes the series of identical rooms from the maze.

  5. I wonder if there exists a ranking of mazes in adventure games, ranked with different keys like, being non-euclidean (this ?), having deaths (Kyrandia 1), having mandatory items far away from the exit (KQ5 and Kyrandia 1), being pure mazes and no puzzle element to it (again Kyrandia 1), being huge (mmm, again ..).

    1. I don't think so, well, not any that wouldn't just be a clickbait article. Considering how many obnoxious mazes there have been in adventure games over the years you'd think there would be.