Help us choose the games for 1994!

Please visit the Year Ahead post for 1994 to help us plan the upcoming games to be covered on the blog!

Tuesday, 18 June 2024

Myst - If on a Winter's Night a Traveler

Written by Vetinari

Previously on The Adventurer's Guild, we were on a dock on a Myst-erious island, and we were preparing to explore our surroundings.

Right at our side when we start, there is a submerged ship that is at the moment unaccessible.

A pirate I was meant to be...
At the end of the dock we find a lever, which we can pull without any apparent effect. On a nearby hill there is a big cogwheel, near which another lever is present. Throwing this also has no effect.

The background music turns ominous here, for no apparent reason...
Continuing towards the interior of this small island, we find some stairs that lead us higher on a gently sloping hill. Right before we arrive at the first building (a sort of circular neo-classical rotunda) we find a letter laying on the grass.
I doubt that I am the Catherine to whom this is addressed to.
O-kay, so these levers that I found are apparently "marker" switches, and I should count them all and then input the number in the imager (?) inside the fore-chamber near the docks? What is all this? Maybe the fore-chamber is this circular building that I am close to? I approach (activating another one of these switches that sits by the door) and enter it.
Seems like a dentist's office to me.
Somehow I doubt that this contraption is the imager, and that this is the forechamber, since when I sit on the chair the view switches to a panel with sliders and numbers, where I find out that I can input a date, not a single digit (or maximum two, I hope). There is also a light switch by the door, which turns off the light in the room. When the light is off, by entering a date in the panel, we can make the display on the left show a constellation of stars.
Sadly, no easter egg for this particular date.
Anyway, I proceed to the outside of the next building, which seems like a greek temple or somesuch.
Seems like the architects in charge of this place were big on Jefferson style.
This also seems to be the highest point on the island, and there is a path which goes off through a columnade to a small conifer wood.
Silver firs most probably.
Near each of the columns there are some tiles with figures on them, which on closer examination can be pressed. This action changes their status from "red" to "green". The eight figures are a bird, an eye, a snake, a spider, an anchor, a leaf, an arrow and a cross.
Is that an ostrich? I am not too keen on ornithology.
In the middle of a fountain there is a model of a submerged ship. There is also another marker switch nearby, which I pull.
Sure bet that raising this model will also raise the ship anchored at the docks.
Entering the "temple" reveals what would seem a very nice study room. It has an octagonal shape, with each wall having some point of interest: one bookcase, two paintings, two book stands, a fireplace, the exit door.
But no place to sit anywhere.
Hanging on one wall there is also something which is quite clearly a map of the island. Checking it closely, it would seem that all the locations where I threw a marker switch are now highlighted on the map diagram, so this pretty clearly hints that I should find and activate them all.
From the dimensions of the island, I guess there's another four or five maximum.
When I click on the two paintings which hang on the walls, something interesting happens. When I operate the one that shows a staircase with a corridor, the bookcase retracts into the floor and the staircase/corridor from the painting appears, leading who knows where. At the same time, the exit door from the building closes up. When instead I use the painting which shows the open door to the columnade, the exit door opens but the staircase gets back to being a bookcase.
I always wanted something like this in my house.
Also of interest are the two books sitting on the book stands. In fact one of them is red and the other one blue, and besides them there are two pages, also respectively red and blue.
Maybe it's actually a white page and it's a trick of the light.
When I click on one of the books all I get is a window which only displays static and emits white noise. When I insert the coloured page in the related book however, something happens.
Okay, this guy creeps me out.
In each of the books some guy appears, telling me (while interspersed by static and white noise) that they are trapped inside the books and that only by inserting more red (or blue, respectively) pages I can free them.
Static and white noise is so 1990s. With modern DAB and DVB this wouldn't cut it.
I also catch that their names are apparently Sirrus and Achenar. (Actually I don't – no subtitles, remember? – but we find these names written down shortly afterwards, so it's pretty easy to connect the dots).

So, I think that we got our main quest. Find these red and blue pages and insert them into these books to (possibly?) free these two guys.
Where's Herschel Biggs when you need him?
Checking the bookcase it would seem that almost all of the books on it have been burned. Only four seem to remain unscathed. All of them are travel journals detailing the journeys of this guy Atrus (ostensibly the same Atrus that wrote the note near the docks, even if the handwriting seems slightly different) into some parallel worlds, which he calls "Ages". It is not clear if Atrus creates or just discovers these Ages by writing about them into books, but apparently he can change the characteristics of the ages and what is contained inside them (albeit with some effort) by modifying the books describing them.

The first book details the age of Channelwood, which is apparently a water world with just some trees emerging, upon which the monkey-like inhabitants of the world live in stilt houses.
The journals are also dotted with diagrams and drawings.
The second talks about the Stoneship age, so called because Atrus tried to evoke a ship into the world but only managed to make it stuck inside a rocky island.
How did the ship got out at such an odd angle?
This book also details some interesting constellations.
Hmmm... where I have seen this before?
The third book is about a volcanic world with meteorites falling from the sky, which Atrus calls the Selenitic age, and on which he apparently constructed and tested various inventions. Unfortunately many pages from this diary are discoloured and almost blank.
This drawing is obviously something that will be needed for some later puzzle.
The last of these four books describes an age with a constantly grey sky, on which Atrus sided with a group of people which were constantly harassed and raided by some pirates. He constructed a rotating fortress to help these people defeat the raiders, and then left.
Apparently this is called the Mechanical age.
Throughout all of the diaries, he also talks about his wife, Catherine, and their two sons Achenar and Sirrus, by whom he is accompanied in some of his extra-planar travels, and whom he also leaves behind in some cases to fend for their own.

Strangely enough, from what is described in the journals Sirrus and Achenar seem to be young boys, but the two guys trapped inside the books are clearly grown men. So I have the strong impression that these journals are seriously out of date, and something else happened in the meantime.

Before exploring the corridor behind the bookcase/staircase combination, I find another interesting feature of this room. If I get inside the fireplace, there is a button which encloses it with a metal door. The lower part of the door is such that I can then insert a pattern into it but, since I have no idea of what the pattern should be, it does nothing.
Something for later, I presume.
At the end of the secret corridor I find an elevator which travels between two levels: the one on the ground, from where I start, is apparently called the “Library”.
See, it says it right there.
The other one, which is reached by some horizontal shift as well as the more common vertical one, is instead the “Tower” level.
Can you still call it an elevator if it travels diagonally?
The Tower is composed by two ladders going up to a catwalk, and identified by two symbols, a book and a key. Right now the book one seems to have a sort of opening at the top, but you can't interact with it or do anything else.
You do not find anything up there.
The one with the key is even less interesting, since it just goes up to a featureless brick wall.

The exploration of this part of the island has taken a pretty long time (especially with all the book reading), so let's stop here and we will continue next time.

Session Time: 1 hour 30 minutes

Total Time: 1 hour 40 minutes

Note Regarding Spoilers and Companion Assist Points: There’s a set of rules regarding spoilers and companion assist points. Please read it here before making any comments that could be considered a spoiler in any way. The short of it is that no points will be given for hints or spoilers given in advance of me requiring one. Please...try not to spoil any part of the game for me...unless I really obviously need the help...or I specifically request assistance. In this instance, I've not made any requests for assistance. Thanks!



20 comments:

  1. O-kay, so these levers that I found are apparently "marker" switches, and I should count them all and then input the number in the imager

    In real life, this would be the worst combination. A stranger comes upon this note, then goes to the lock. "Does 1 work? No? Okay, let's try 2. Um, now 3..."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. first puzzle for many .. and it's indeed terrible

      Delete
    2. Eh, it's not great, but calling it terrible is a bit of a stretch.

      Delete
  2. The Sirrus and Achenar names are clearly based on the stars Sirius and Achernar.

    ReplyDelete
  3. One interesting trick this game uses to keep video file sizes down is to make them play in small areas of the screen - in the elevator only the window is necessary to create the illusion of being moved, for example.

    ReplyDelete
  4. For the record, here's transcripts of the dialogue from the guys in the books, since it can be a bit hard to make out (by design, the entire idea is that they're trying to communicate through a very faulty communications channel - as a result, they're mostly concerned with trying to get you to understand what they want you to do, so there's a lot of unfinished and interrupted sentences here and not a whole lot of substance - mostly them repeating "red pages" and "blue pages" a lot to make you at least pick up those words, which it seems like you did):

    Red book: "Who are you… You must help me, please… Bring me the red page… I can't… I can't see you… hear me… I need a red page, you must bring me a red page… Please bring … beg of you, bring the page… Help me… I am Sirrus… Given up long ago… There is one thing I need to be rescued… You must…"

    Blue book: "Sirrus? Is that you? … who are you? … see you … Achenar … to help me … to bring … blue pages to … forever and ever … blue pages… I must have the blue pages… Bring them to me, please."

    ReplyDelete
  5. Also, it's really fascinating to read these fresh comments on this initial portion of the game. You talked about "revisiting it" in the initial post, but all of this seems very new to you. How much did you play it back then?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I played all of it, but frankly speaking I remember almost nothing about it (just the fact that you travel to various worlds via books).

      Delete
  6. I was not expecting a Calvino quote, much more so in the title of the post. While reading I kept thinking, is the game a constant breaking of the 4th wall? Is it a game about playing/enjoying a game? Or does the quote have to do with the books of Myst. I can't say I figured it out, but neither can I say the same for that Calvino book... :D

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is anecdotal, but this is the second account I've read in the past week or so where someone starting the game has zvffrq gur qbbe naq punzore evtug arkg gb jurer lbh fgneg.

    I wonder now if this is poor design on the game's part. Although it's interesting that you ernq gur abgr ohg qvqa'g tb onpx gb rkcyber gur qbpx nern.

    Anyway, you'll get to it sooner or later! For many, many years this start of the game bewildered and repelled me. No guidance! No context! I'm glad I found a way in eventually but it sure wasn't easy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Out of curiosity, I looked at the manual for the game. It doesn't have any sort of "here's how to start the game" walkthroughs like previous games had. Maybe they should have done that,as a way to orient people with a new style of game.

      Delete
    2. yeah, to me it feels closer to those 80s adventures like Zord where you are just thrown into a world and have to figure out what to do.

      Very different to the famous approach of games like Fate of Atlantis where you have the interactive intro (with no bottom bar), and then the new york scene which sort of works as a tutorial, with tons of hinting, and 3 alternate solutions to the doorman puzzle

      Delete
    3. >I wonder now if this is poor design on the game's part.

      I think it's actually what they assumed players would do.
      Ybbx ng gur fcrpvsvp jbeqvat va gur abgr, vg fcryyf bhg irel fcrpvsvpnyyl jurer gur vzntre vf ybpngrq. Vg nyfb gryyf lbh gb ragre gur ahzore bs "Znexre Fjvgpurf", juvpu vg vfa'g RAGVRYL pyrne jung ersref gb (bx, vg'f cerggl boivbhf, ohg V guvax gurl nffhzrq n ahzore bs cynlref jbhyq or engure qhzo), ohg gur vzntre pna or frg gb fubj n ubybtenz bs bar, rkcynvavat rknpgyl jung lbh'er zrnag gb or ybbxvat sbe.
      Gb zr, guvf vzcyvrf gur vagraqrq beqre bs riragf jnf sbe n cynlre gb svaq gur abgr, hfr gur vasb va gung gb svaq gur sberpunzore naq gur vzntre, naq gura hfr gur vzntre gb yrnea jung n Znexre Fjvgpu vf, gura tbvat nebhaq gur vfynaq pbhagvat gurz gb trg gur pbeerpg ahzore gb ragre.

      Delete
    4. Heh, I compared the game with Zork in a comment on the previous post. It really does have its share of similarities with that, doesn't it?
      Myst in general is the kind of atmospheric game that wants the player to take it a bit slow and just explore and take the world in, I think including notes in the manual for "how to start the game" would work against that. "Getting to the game" isn't really the point, and especially a complete newcomer to this type of game would definitely want to just walk around the island a bit and get vowed by the atmosphere.
      Gur vfynaq vfa'g irel ovt, naq zbfg guvatf lbh pna vagrenpg jvgu ner boivbhfyl zrnag gb or vagrenpgrq jvgu va bar irel fcrpvsvp znaare lbh arrq gb svaq pyhrf gbjneq. Svthevat bhg jung qverpgvba gur tnzr vf cbvagvat lbh va fubhyqa'g gnxr gung ybat.

      Delete
    5. especially a complete newcomer to this type of game would definitely want to just walk around the island a bit and get vowed by the atmosphere.

      It could be my PC vs MAC bias, but I'll disagree, saying, at least at that point in history, it would have been necessary because the people being marketed to as Mac users weren't as nerdy or tech-savvy, and might have had less overall experiences with computer gaming in general. I think it needed a quick tutorial, like: "Start in the main room. Press buttons X and Y. See how you can look around? Let's have you go into this other room and use an object. See? It's easy! Now it's your turn."

      Or something like Alex Romanov said, something similar to Fate of Atlantis. This was a new style of game, and I think (in retrospect) they should have done a little more handholding. I personally had no problems with learning the game back then, I just didn't like the game, but I can see it from the other side now.

      Delete
    6. That's basically how the manual words it, though...?
      Myst was in general trying to as intuitive as possible with its pure "just click to do what can be done" controls that I really don't think there's anything a tutorial could've really done. I've never heard of anyone struggling to understand how to control Myst.

      Delete
    7. I can't help but feel like your point is undercut by how it's those supposedly tech-savvier users who couldn't figure out the controls, while Mac and later, Windows users didn't have any real trouble. Maybe if you spend all day installing sound cards you don't have any memory left to figure out how to move without a tutorial. ;p

      There's only one part I'd say the game dropped the ball on making unintuitive, and I'll point it out when we see it, pretty soon.

      Delete
  8. Given that I know the game considerably well, I don't have much to add here, since you didn't do a lot here, and some of what you did was arguably a little out of order, that is, focusing on all four books at once rather than just one at a time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nah, I disagree there. Reading all the books at once is definitely recommended to get the full idea of what's going on here, and it's also what absolutely everyone that played the game did.
      Jul jbhyq lbh qb vg qvssreragyl hayrff lbh jrer fvggvat gurer jvgu lbhe abfr va n thvqr? Fbzrbar whfg cynlvat gur tnzr oyvaq vfa'g tbvat gb zntvpnyyl thrff gung rnpu obbx pbaarpgf gb n jubyyl frcnengr frg bs chmmyrf gung pna or gnpxyrq va nal beqre, ernq bar naq gura vtaber nyy gur bguref pbzcyrgryl hagvy ur'f pbzcyrgrq rirel chmmyr pbaarpgrq gb gung cnegvphyne obbx. Whfg qbrfa'g znxr zhpu frafr.

      Delete

Note Regarding Spoilers and Companion Assist Points: There's a set of rules regarding spoilers and companion assist points. Please read it here before making any comments that could be considered a spoiler in any way. The short of it is that no points will be given for hints or spoilers given in advance of the reviewer requiring one. Please...try not to spoil any part of the game...unless they really obviously need the help...or they specifically request assistance.

If this is a game introduction post: This is your opportunity for readers to bet 10 CAPs (only if they already have them) that the reviewer won't be able to solve a puzzle without putting in an official Request for Assistance: remember to use ROT13 for betting. If you get it right, you will be rewarded with 50 CAPs in return.
It's also your chance to predict what the final rating will be for the game. Voters can predict whatever score they want, regardless of whether someone else has already chosen it. All score votes and puzzle bets must be placed before the next gameplay post appears. The winner will be awarded 10 CAPs.

Commenting on old entries: We encourage and appreciate comments on all posts, not just the most recent one. There is need to worry about "necroposting" comments on old entries, there is no time limit on when you may comment, except for contests and score guesses.