The box cover art gives us subtle clues to our future destinations. |
Wait, why do I hear knocking at my door?“Ahem, I heard there was a police game being played, and... wait! You’re not Alex!”
Okay, but I probably won’t need your help with this title. Neither of the title characters are likely to marry a reformed prostitute, and they’re more likely to run over a speeding motorist than to pull her over.
“I don’t care for your attitude. Remember, I can still take you downtown.”
Seriously, Officer Walls, Alex’s house is just a few doors down. I’m sure he wouldn’t mind an unexpected dinner guest.
“Good luck without me, then. You’re turning your back on the most trusted authority in police procedural adventure gaming in the 19th century!”
Wow. I thought he would never leave.
I really need to install a better deadbolt lock on my door. |
But first, a little backstory. Who are Sam and Max, and what makes them tick? Besides, perhaps, a bomb that Max might or might not be carrying...
When Steve Purcell was just a kid in the 70s, he and his brother Dave were budding artists. Dave would draw crude comics for his own pleasure, dreaming of the future, and sometimes, big brother Steve would finish the comics, add pages, or mess with the story lines. The characters of Freelance Policemen Sam & Max were created by Dave and were a favorite in his collection.
A crude early comic book cover mock-up by Dave Purcell |
The first officially published Sam & Max strip |
Fast forward a few years to 1987, when Purcell would be friends with another comic artist, Steve Moncuse, who published a small, indy book about the Fish Police. Wanting to expand to another comic book in the lineup, Sam & Max: Freelance Police would soon grace the printed page as a bona-fide comic book.
Monkeys Violating the Heavenly Temple was the first book-length Sam & Max story |
Early art for Wally’s office in Monkey Island 2 |
From the first issue of The Adventurer |
During the design of the first Monkey Island game, the programmers needed to be trained in how to use the SCUMM system. Steve had created a mock-up of Sam & Max’s office along with the two characters to be used as a training tool. This would lay the groundwork for a full-fledged game, born of the desire to expand the LucasArts catalog with a new property, as well as answering the fan requests for more of the fluffy bunny and gruff dog from the newsletter pages.
Unlike their other titles, Steve Purcell retained the rights to the characters, which is why the games have continued long after Steve and adventure gaming both departed LucasArts.
The game largely follows a 1988 storyline from the books. I won’t be posting those comics here, because I wouldn’t want to spoil the game for myself or anyone else playing along. But I read them long ago, in a collection of all the published comics at the time, in The Collected Sam & Max: Surfing the Highway, a book I once owned and read lovingly, back in the late 90s. My copy was later water damaged when an apartment I lived in was flooded, so I’ve since lost that. The Telltale Games re-release has also gone out of print, so when I do decide to read again, it will have to be online.
Just around the corner in this story is the animated series |
A sequel to the game was being worked on around 2001, but the developer went bankrupt before it could be finished. Soon after, LucasArts started work on a sequel, but then abruptly pulled the plug when they decided that they didn’t want to make adventure games anymore. (From this point onward, about 99.999% of the company output was Star Wars titles, and if you surf to lucasarts.com today, it redirects to a Star Wars page).
So, we won’t be talking about the next game in the series until the TAG blog reaches 2006, so I have to make sure to enjoy this experience as much as I can right now. (Those later games, episodic releases from Telltale Games, are being remastered as we speak, with the next release expected for Spring 2024.) Telltale was founded by former LucasArts employees soon after the 2004 Sam & Max cancellation, including a couple of designers from the original Sam & Max game, so it was a no-brainer for them to court Steve Purcell to their lineup.
Now, for the game at hand. For as much as I have said about the game so far, I remember very little. The last time I played it was 17 years ago, back in 2006, before I dug my heels into the Telltale release that was coming out. So, I’m going in blind, I don’t think I remember a single thing about this game, except what the pictures on the game box would tell me. I know we are visiting a very large ball of twine, and I suspect we need to collect that and bring it with us to our playthrough of Grim Fandango in a few game years, to distract the very, very large cat.
I still have many CDs from the 90s, some of which are rather hard to get running on modern systems |
Rear box cover for the original release |
Many of the places we will be visiting in this game are in fact real, or parodies of real places. For example, most mentions of the game include the World’s Largest Ball of Twine, which very much exists in rural Kansas. Refreshments will be available at Snuckey’s, a clear parody of Stuckey’s, a chain of midwest gas-and-go stops along busy travel roads. The chain loved the references in the comics and games. Purcell put them in because it reminded him of road trips from his childhood, wanting Dad to pull over at each one.
But enough of this history lesson. On with the game!
It’s the Flying Toasters screensaver! |
We start the game with an evil mad scientist aiming an apparatus at a woman bound with rope in his secret lair. It seems that she went out with him on a blind date, and he turned out to be a creep.
“We’ve only gone out three times, and you’re already telling me you just want to be friends? You never gave me a chance, and for that, you’ll fry like a pork sausage!”Cue the entrance of our intrepid heroes.So, we meet our new friends for this game. On the right is Sam. He’s described as a “canine shamus”, who looks very much like McGruff the Crime Dog from the 70s and 80s, but with the suit of Sergeant Friday instead of Peter Falk’s raincoat. He’s ready to take a bite out of crime, quite literally if possible. In this game, he’s voiced by Bill Farmer, who so far has him sounding perfectly like a classic 1950s noir gumshoe.
“I think I’d rather go out with someone a little more... unpredictable.”
His more excitable partner on the left of the screen is Max. He’s a “hyperkinetic rabbity thing” that can probably best be described as a cross between a cute, fluffy rabbit doll and Stewie from Family Guy. He’s worse than a gun, because he doesn’t have a safety switch to hold him back, except the strength of Sam at times. He’s eager to do everything we wish, deep down in the back of our minds, could be done to evil criminals, if only we didn’t have a conscience.
“Looks like a marginally volatile hostage situation, Max.”And so the introduction shows us the modus operandi for the anthropomorphic duo, which is to arrive at a crime scene, quickly deduce that evil is afoot and open up a can of Andy Sipowicz on it. The violence in this sequence is mostly off-screen.And it turns out that the evil scientist was really an evil robot.
“Ooh! Does this mean we get to kick some puffy, white, mad scientist butt?”
“Can’t think of a reason not to!”
“That’s no head, Max, it’s one damned ugly time bomb!”So, the credits roll, with black & white film noir style images above and below. Of special note on this screen would be co-designer Collette Michaud. During the making of this game, she and Steve Purcell married.
“Maybe we can ditch the head somewhere while the credits are running. Mind if I drive?”
“Not if you don’t mind me clawing at the dash and shrieking like a cheerleader.”
As a bit of game trivia, there was talk about making the game black and white, like the comics. They decided against it, but who knows, it might have worked. The next year, a black & white movie made millions and spawned a movie empire for a convenience store clerk. More recently, a black and white adventure game surpassed its Kickstarter goals and is in active development.And now, let’s break the fourth wall.Hey, let’s not forget about the bomb.
Just then, the phone starts to ring. I’ve done my best to screenshot as much of the animation as I could, but basically, Sam makes sure that Max doesn’t answer the phone.And this brings us to the end of the introduction sequence, and now we can explore the game world. But first, let’s take a look at the interface.Gone are the verbs and inventory taking up a third of the screen; Day of the Tentacle would be their last game to ever have that. With this game, they emulated Sierra (a little), and then would go on to do either a coin interface (Full Throttle, Curse of Monkey Island) or even flirt with tank controls (Grim Fandango).
From the game manual |
But these are very small gripes. On the plus side, we are no longer losing a third of the screen to the interface, which was one of LucasArts’ few notable mistakes of the past.In the bottom left of the game screen is a cardboard box. That’s your inventory. Click on there, and you’ll see all your worldly possessions. Sadly, we don’t have any right now. You can also click on icons here instead of using the right mouse button, for use either in the box (say, looking at an inventory item) or to carry out of the box.
So now, let’s talk about the Max icon. It’s not like the previous LucasArts games, where the icon of another player means changing who is in charge. It’s basically a way for Sam to use Max as a solution, much like Officer Bonds uses his gun.Everything that doesn’t advance the plot is usually entertaining. Using the answering machine, for example, at this time plays us a spam message.
Also, have you noticed how many LucasArts games require the use of answering machines? Seriously. Maniac Mansion. Zak McKracken. Day of the Tentacle. Grim Fandango. I’m sure there’s probably one hidden in a Tie-Fighter game somewhere, no doubt.
Using the darts, Max will remove them from the board, step away, and throw them, miraculously landing in the same configuration. He’s pretty talented.Walking to the right, the screen scrolls with us, and as I try to collect the moldy sandwich on the floor, Max jumps in and feeds it to his roach farm. Cute animations the whole way.
In the closet is a blacklight bulb. I pick that up. Back on Max’s desk, I turn on the TV, and it’s nothing but static. Moving the antenna around, and suddenly I’m watching a quality show.Oh, wait, that’s not it.
So, this seems like a great time to pause the game and ask you to place your wagers. This is the first in the series, so there’s not much to compare it to. Recent LucasArts games have been scoring rather high lately, but as lawyers often say in their ads, “past performance is no guarantee of future results.” The most recent cartoonish LucasArts game, Day of the Tentacle, scored a very healthy 72. Where will this one land?
Session Time: 10 minutes
Note Regarding Spoilers and Companion Assist Points: There's a set of rules regarding spoilers and companion assist points. Please read it here before making any comments that could be considered a spoiler in any way. The short of it is that no CAPs will be given for hints or spoilers given in advance of me requiring one. As this is an introductory post, it's an opportunity for readers to bet 10 CAPs (only if they already have them) that I won't be able to solve a puzzle without putting in an official Request for Assistance: remember to use ROT13 for betting. If you get it right, you will be rewarded with 20 CAPs in return. It's also your chance to predict what the final rating will be for the game. Voters can predict whatever score they want, regardless of whether someone else has already chosen it. All correct (or nearest) votes will go into a draw.
67
ReplyDeleteThe game has some excellent aspects but I think the interface, puzzle design and story will weigh it down.
I thought I overused screenshots sometimes. Probably would have been a good idea to find a video of the intro online or take one yourself.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I'm going to go with 65. Some improvements over the old games, but I suspect puzzles won't be that high given how little this one is talked up. Could be wrong though.
I forgot about this at the time, but Max in a weird sense was the mascot of Lucasarts at this time, since IIRC, he appeared as a cameo in most games from Monkey Island 1 until they ceased operations as a developer. Some less subtle than others, like in Jedi Knight where you could shoot but not kill him in one level.
DeleteI've forgotten where he appears in Monkey Island 1, but wouldn't his appearance on the totem pole in Indy's office in Last Crusade predate it?
DeleteIn The Secret of Monkey Island, one of the little idols in front of the giant monkey head is Sam and Max.
DeleteAh, right, now I remember. Thanks!
DeleteIn my defense, I've tried to forget about the Last Crusade game as much as possible.
DeleteLast Crusade isn't one of my favorites by any stretch. I appreciate some things it's trying to do, but I wish it did them in a more interesting way.
DeleteBut it's a game that's been on my mind a lot lately, because in the past weeks I have (with some much needed help) been implementing the GUI for the 16 color Macintosh version in ScummVM.
Last Crusade had many of the problems of other film adaptations -- you knew how it was going to end, for one. But they used material deleted from the film but not the script (sometimes by accident), and not just added alternate solutions but encouraged them, giving you a better score for doing so. Of course, they kept the scoring system somewhat hidden (if you didn't bother pressing the button to see the score, you'd never notice it).
DeleteThere's not a whole lot of adventure game adaptations of movies, but Last Crusade would be one of the better ones, even if it wasn't a great LucasArts game. And without it, Guybrush wouldn't be able to offer us any fine leather jackets for sale.
>if you didn't bother pressing the button to see the score,
Delete>you'd never notice it
What, you never loaded nor saved a game? Or is this a ScummVM quirk I'm too DOSBox-purist to understand?
Fate of Atlantis is the game where the score is only visible by pressing "i" during gameplay.
I suppose I was thinking of Fate, then. And I haven't played Last Crusade in anything but ScummVM for ages, I guess. ScummVM defaults to it's own save/load screen for a lot of games unless you choose to use the native ones. Which, in the case of some older games, like Sierra AGI titles and early Lucas, the Scumm interface is much better.
DeleteI am being pure for the Sam & Max playthrough, though, and using DosBox.
> What, you never loaded nor saved a game? Or is this a ScummVM quirk I'm too DOSBox-purist to understand?
DeleteScummVM does have its own custom dialog for saving/loading in the LucasArts/Lucasfilm games, because it was easier that way. But ScummVM 2.7.0 (released earlier this year) finally did implement the original GUI and dialogs for most of them. (The NEWS file mentions "DOS, Windows, Amiga, Macintosh, FM-Towns, SegaCD, Atari ST, NES and Commodore 64 versions".)
The old Mac versions of Loom and Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade use Mac file picker dialogs. That doesn't make sense in ScummVM, where you name the save game but not the file itself. But ScummVM 2.8.0 will have something that looks like one if you squint a little. But I'm sure there's room for improvements, because this is very recent work.
83. I'm not going to try to justify it, I just have a hunch it will go high and long.
ReplyDeleteAlso, that comic with the pirates was pretty great.
A name for this guess will put your guess in the running for the contest.
DeleteAnd he did comics in all the issues of the newsletter, sometimes loosely based on the games, other times Star Wars related, and then a few random ones. The first three issues featured games: Monkey Island (the one you saw), Secret Weapons of the Luftwaffe, Fate of Atlantis.
I think that of the issues of the newsletter related to Star Wars, one was related to "X-Wing" and other ro "Dark Forces", so they were algo related to Lucasarts games.
DeleteThe only ones I can't tie into a game seem to be one Star Wars set on Hoth, which didn't have a game at that time, one involving a Frankenstein's monster and one set around a talk show. Dunno if there were games for those, because I can see some people not knowing that one of these was a tie-in to the god game Afterlife.
Delete1. Planes, Trains & Automobiles was *thanksgiving*? I had in my head it was an Xmas movie but I guess that's cos I'm not from the US.
ReplyDelete2. They remade Dragnet but serious even after the Dan Ackroyd/Tom Hanks comedy???
3. uh I guess this will be pretty high unless the jokes haven't aged well or the puzzles were worse than I recall, so I'm gonna say 86
If memory serves, they remade Dragnet twice after that. The first one was a first-run syndicated series right around the cusp of the 90s.
Delete@Ross yeah, there was a pathetic attempt as a "New Dragnet" a couple of years after the movie, but with new characters and none of the magic of wither the original series or the movie.
DeleteThe 2003 series had good acting, but came out while there were a million other crime shows on TV, so it didn't stand out. Even with Al Bundy as the headliner. To be fair, it was far from his first police role, but generally, people really prefer him in humorous roles, like most recently in Modern Family.
@Andy Yeah, a Thanksgiving film. From my view at least, Thanksgiving films usually involve coming home to see your own family, and Christmas films involve going to visit extended family.
DeleteHome Alone breaks that standard, kind of. The extended family gathers at the house, and then leaves on a trip together. But the movie is them coming back home. So it almost does both.
"came out while there were a million other crime shows on TV"
DeleteEh? Since when has that ever stopped a mediocre crime series from lasting a decade or more? In seriousness, I don't see what's so special about that year even considering the popularity of CSI. It's like that every year, and it's especially gotten bad these days since nobody ever seems to cancel crime shows any more.
No don’t send Jim to my house!
ReplyDeleteIt is not his custom to go where he is not wanted.
DeleteAs a bit of game trivia, there was talk about making the game black and white, like the comics. They decided against it, but who knows, it might have worked.
ReplyDeleteAccording to the manual, you can press "b" to enable black and white mode.
I'm going for 77. The nonsensical humour may spill over into nonsensical puzzles. The whole thing felt a bit like an acid trip to me (even though I've never had one), so not my cup of tea but I'm interested to see some-one else's take on the craziness.
ReplyDeleteI'm gonna go 74. I liked it. But the interface frustrated me, the Americana didn't translate well, and good lord did I tire of the relentless attempts at humour in the dialogue. I think DOTT was better... but feel that scored a little lower than it deserved (I would have had it at around 76). All told, it's a really solid, fun, adventure game - it's not one of my top 10, but I can see how it would be for some.
ReplyDeleteI'll hazard a 75 - I replayed it some years ago and liked it quite a bit.
ReplyDeleteOh man, I have such mixed feelings about this game. Back in the '90s it felt like such a stumble from LucasArts, as I just could not find a way to enjoy it. The irreverent nonsense of the dialogue and utterly confusing puzzles, the unnaturally aggressive nature of the characters, the horrible new interface (I missed the verbs so much) and all the references to Americana which were totally lost on me.
ReplyDeleteBut at the same time it has the LucasArts charm and a certain legacy that I manage to feel affection for. The game looks gorgeous and made me laugh.
I'll look forward to playing along and seeing how it goes for me now. I'd personally rate the game relatively low based on memories, but I'll guess the score here will be 69.
I was never a big fan of the original Sam&Max since it always seemed very disjointed to me. I replayed it recently and had the same impression.
ReplyDeleteSo the game gets a low 59 from me.
The Telltale episodic adventures, on the other hand, were excellent.
I'll guess a 70 because it is a number which appears a few times in the post and it puts the game slightly lower than "Day of the Tentacle". What LeftHandedMatt has said about their feelings about the game could be also applied to me; although "Sam and Max" still has the "Lucasarts charm", its some kind of lesser charm compared to the previous games.
ReplyDeleteWell, this has more mixed views than I was expecting, but it doesn't seem to have been remembered overly well.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed it at the time - the cartoony Lucasarts humour was all there, and even though I'm not American I was amused by the references but I think it was let down by some obscure puzzle design.
I'll go a 68.
Stumbled on your article. We search our own names because of some weird George Lucas imposter spreading lies about us on the internet. He's not very believable, but it's concerning. Your article is accurate, but we got married after the game was shipped. You didn't get far, there's more to the game, but I guess it's not a fun game now.
ReplyDeleteHello Collette,
DeleteThis is just the beginning! The author will be producing new blogs detailing his progress through the game in subsequent instalments. At the end he will provide his final thoughts and a score. You may wish to check back to follow along!
I played all the LucasArts games almost at the time of their release. Maniac Mansion was incredible, I still love that game, but Sam &Max was the first one that I Didn't like. I missed the verbs UI very much, the humour didn't appeal to me and Max was very, very annoying. Didn't like that much Full Throttle either. For my, the best LucasArts is the classic LucasArts: from Maniac Mansion until Day of the Tentacle. My guess is 62
ReplyDeletethere are good bits but I'll predict lower rather than higher
ReplyDeletelet's say 66
Most of the numbers I'd have picked are already taken, but 76 still seems to be available... So I say 76! I'd have rated DOTT higher, and I really like this one as well, I've replayed it multiple times since release. The of the wall comedy is not everyone's cup of tea I suppose, but I really loved it.
ReplyDeleteGratuitous violence is my forte! 72!
ReplyDeleteBefore I forget, let's try a bet: Zvpunry jvyy unir gebhoyr svaqvat/gnxvat gur yraf va gur pneaviny. Lnl sbe ab zbhfrbire grkgf.
ReplyDeleteThis is an amazing adventure from LucasArts .. I will guess a 80
ReplyDeleteUnless the rules have changed recently, it's too late to guess the rating after the second post on the game.
Delete